October 15, 2026
The tall Sheplers sign at the southeast corner of the Interstate 25 and Orchard Road interchange has stood there since 1977. No Sheplers store has operated under it since 2015. In August, the Greenwood Village City Council voted 4–3 to let it stay as the building below it moves from western wear to a 1,000-seat worship center. That vote did real work. If council had said nothing, the sign would have been removed with the remodel.
The sign doesn't comply with Greenwood Village's current sign code. As The Villager reported, it was already up when the city annexed the property in 1987. That made it grandfathered "as long as it/the property is not changed."
The Denver Post's account of the meeting, which came from its partner BusinessDen, explains the rest. City staff said the sign was grandfathered because it was considered to refer to the current tenant, Boot Barn. Once the church moved in, the sign would no longer refer to the occupant. After six months it could be considered abandoned and eventually removed. According to The Villager, staff also said that unless council made "an affirmative decision" to keep the sign, it would have to come down as part of the remodel.
So the sign's legal status came from what was going on underneath it. The building changing hands was enough to put it at risk.
The Planning & Zoning Commission approved the church project unanimously on August 4 and sent the sign question to the City Council. Council took it up on August 17. Per the Denver Post, council members spent more time on the sign than on the church.
The Villager laid out where each member landed, and the split followed district lines:
The Denver Post caught the tone of the debate. Wiesner called the sign "an eyesore" that "does not fit in with the city." Barnacle answered, "Have you no mercy or nostalgia, Mr. Wiesner?" Mayor George Lantz said he knew people who found the sign "very objectionable because it's very large." Schneiderman said, "I've lived here almost my entire life. I love the sign."
With the two District 3 votes and the District 4 deferral to them, Schneiderman's vote made it four. The sign stayed by a single vote.
The sign question came up only because the building's new use was legal at all. That took a separate decision that got far less attention.
In 2015, Greenwood Village rewrote the allowed uses in its Mixed Commercial zone to emphasize revenue generation. According to The Villager, that effectively removed places of worship and other civic uses, which the zone had allowed until then. On February 2, 2026, council reversed course and added places of worship and event centers back as special uses in that zone. The amendment passed unanimously on the consent agenda, with no council discussion and no public input. Grace Chapel officials were in the audience.
A week before that vote, on January 27, a neighborhood input meeting at City Hall drew six neighbors. A required traffic impact study found that no road improvements were needed, because the building would be used mostly on Sundays, when traffic is light. At the August 17 meeting, church officials said the building would be used seven days a week, including as coworking space and a coffee shop.
Put in order, the sign survived three separate decisions. Council changed the zoning in February, the commission approved the project on August 4, and on August 17 council approved the permit, site plan and sign by a 4–3 vote.
According to Sheplers' own company history, the Wichita, Kansas, company opened its third store here in 1977, listed under Englewood. Boot Barn bought Sheplers, Inc. in July 2015, along with its 25 stores and its online business. After that, the Orchard Road store kept selling the same kind of merchandise under the Boot Barn name.
The land has changed hands twice since. Denver-based Sidford Capital bought it in 2019 for $8.3 million. Grace Chapel's project page says the church bought it on August 28, 2026, for about $11 million.
Grace Chapel's senior pastor, Josh Weidmann, had worked on the deal for 13 months. He told council it was "the No. 1 question we had over the last 13 months: Will the sign stay?" Per the Denver Post, he remembered seeing the sign from the highway as a child and wondering, "What's it like in that building? That's where the cowboys go." The church has been on I-25 since 1995, in a former car dealership across from Park Meadows Mall.
According to The Villager, Weidmann asked to keep the sign as it is, with only necessary repairs and no changes to the sign or its Sheplers message. That makes the outcome unusual. For the foreseeable future, a sign for a brand with no store at this exit will stand over a church.
Elsewhere in the metro, keeping a vintage sign has taken more work. In January 2026, the Denver Post reported that the Branding Iron Motel's neon sign in Aurora was restored, though a city-imposed egress fee nearly derailed the effort. The same story described the Riviera Motel sign in Aurora as a survivor without reporting a completed restoration. In Denver, the Benjamin Moore neon sign was replaced with LED two years before that story ran, and its old letters were destroyed and recycled. The Sheplers sign avoided both outcomes because a new owner wanted it and a council majority agreed.
Nothing at the site changes right away. As of today, the dates people have announced are:
| Date | What happens | Source |
|---|---|---|
| August 17, 2026 | Council approves the special use permit, site plan and sign, 4–3 | The Villager |
| August 28, 2026 | Grace Chapel closes on the property | Grace Chapel |
| June 30, 2027 | Boot Barn's lease ends | Grace Chapel |
| July 1, 2027 | Planned groundbreaking | Grace Chapel |
| Fall 2028 | The church's "realistic" move-in target | Grace Chapel |
The church ties the 2028 date to approvals, construction and closing timelines. Plans in the Denver Post account include a new roof, a new entry, more glass across the front and more landscaping. The Villager adds new lighting, a reconfigured parking lot with 257 spaces, a fenced outdoor play area and more open space. The church's early plans for the building also include a public coffee shop and a free counseling center.
Until then, Boot Barn's store locator still lists the store at 8500 East Orchard Road with regular hours. The western-wear store should keep running under the 1977 sign for about eight and a half more months.
If you're curious about the stories behind the buildings in your part of the south metro, or thinking about a home whose character matters to you, Stephanie Watanabe would love to talk it through with you. Let's Connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you're buying your first home, selling a longtime property, or exploring your next investment, Steph Watanabe is committed to making the process seamless and rewarding. With local market expertise, personalized guidance, and a client-first approach, Steph takes the time to understand your goals and provide honest advice every step of the way.